Warning: Not All Career Rules Are True

Photo 53/265 - End GameCorporations often dish up beliefs as truths and then manage you through that lens. I see it all the time in my coaching work. There’s an implicit set of assumptions that underpin the culture of a business. These are all well and good if they happen to jive with your values and beliefs, but crazy-making if they don’t.

Take Bob who was living in the grip of one such “truth” when I began working with him.

A young, talented and ambitious accountant, he’d recently been disappointed to find that he hadn’t even been nominated for the promotion process that would eventually allow him to apply for partnership. But the icing on the cake was the following advice dished out to him by his HR Director:

“You can’t have a career and a good work life balance,”

When I asked him to help me understand, he shared that he wanted to have a life, as much as he wanted to have a career. He was no slouch. He’d work the hours to finish audits on time, and he’d conduct after-hours client review meetings no problem. But when the pressure was off, he’d leave work at six and spend his evenings with his wife and two children, instead of doing the politically required thing of staying at his desk.

This went against the grain for his firm. So, if he wanted a career there he was going to have to choose between two parts of him that he did not want to experience as ever being in conflict.

Reframe The Belief

The first step in our coaching work was to challenge the assumption in the belief.

“Is it true that one cannot have a career and a rich life beyond it?” I asked.

As we talked it through, it became obvious that, while it was true of his company, he could think of lots of other people in his life and in the public eye who had good lives and good careers.

Take Back The Power

Next up was for Bob to consider whose picture of a professional life he was going to follow: his own or his firm’s.

In the former, Bob himself could set goals for himself and decide what was and wasn’t okay for him. In the latter, he’d hand over much of his power to his firm. They’d decide what was appropriate, and Bob would moderate himself to fit in.

He decided that constantly measuring himself against some external standard, as he had been until that point, was no longer for him. Deciding to put himself in the driving seat of his own career allowed him to feel much more confident and resourceful.

Can You Get What You Want Here?

He decided to test out his current firm by having a further conversation with the HRD about how much latitude there actually was on worklife issues. But he returned to me disappointed.

“The partnership is a club,” the HRD had said. “It may say it values worklife balance, but really it expects complete loyalty. Either you’re happy to play by the rules or you’re not.”

We looked at the kind of club this partnership actually was and whether it was one of which Bob really wanted to be a member. He reflected on the phenomenal professionalism on the one hand; on the other he spoke of the failed marriages, the confirmed singletons, the relationships that appeared to exist purely on convenience. He started to square up to the possibility that this was not a club to which he would willingly belong.

Where Can You Get It?

With my support, he then went off and began having tentative chats with people in his professional network. He was trying to get a feel for how life was in other accountancy and professional service firms. Many of them seemed to have similar cultures. But some of the mid-sized, more entrepreneurial ones appeared more open to the possibility that their people might want to have more in their lives than work.

Finally, he was offered and accepted a senior management role for a smaller firm, with a fast-track route to partnership based on how things mutually worked out.

The last time I spoke to him he’d just been promoted, and was delighted.

Bob’s is just one example of how career rules can work against individuals, and how it’s possible, by getting clear of what’s true for you, to find a better fit.

What career rules might you be unduly struggling against? How might using Bob’s example free you up?

Creative Commons License photo credit: Aerokev

No related posts.

17 Responses to Warning: Not All Career Rules Are True
  1. Jen Smith
    September 2, 2010 | 1:10 pm

    It’s so true that there are so many unwritten assumptions and rules within work. Recently I met up with someone I used to work with. He was talking about how there was no teamwork at this workplace anymore and how people just got on with it and grinned and bore it. He went on to say “well, that’s what work is, isn’t it?”. I thought to myself, that isn’t what work is to me!

    • Christine
      September 2, 2010 | 2:02 pm

      Fascinating, isn’t it Jen, how these “truths” work their way into our system and then determine our behaviour. If we let them! Your former colleague’s view of work, no matter how understandable, is pretty sad.

  2. [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Grant Griffiths, Christine Livingston. Christine Livingston said: Warning: Not All Career Rules Are True http://goo.gl/fb/e7IRK [...]

  3. [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Jen Smith and Christine Livingston, Christine Livingston. Christine Livingston said: Warning: Not All Career Rules Are True http://goo.gl/fb/jvjXK [...]

  4. Paula Kiger
    Twitter:
    September 2, 2010 | 4:12 pm

    Christine, this post really touches on an area that is an issue for me. One “twist” I would put on it is that corporate cultures change over time, and in my case I was still living in “original culture” when “different culture” asserted itself. When I was hired here 16 years ago, I was told, “it’s a great place to raise a family.” Seven years ago when I asked a boss if I could skip a meeting in order to go on a field trip with my daughter, he wrote in an email “children come first.” This year, under a different Executive Director, we get generic statements in staff meetings about, “it just doesn’t look like people are working hard enough.” Obviously an organizational culture shift that has taken 16 years is more complicated than one blog comment can really cover, but the point is that we need to be aware that the organizational environment can change, and we need to be attuned to that possibility.

    • Christine
      September 2, 2010 | 5:33 pm

      Thanks for your very astute comment, Paula. What you say about cultures changing is so true and it’s important to pay attention to the shifts. I’ve seen this happen myself, as key players, or the business environment changes. One company I worked for used to “be work hard, play hard” until new management thought that play was too trivial and people began to be reprimanded for light-heartedness.

      I really appreciate your adding to the conversation here.

  5. Julie Walraven | Resume Services
    Twitter:
    September 3, 2010 | 4:40 pm

    Getting behind reading your excellent posts again, Christine! This has been a pet peeve of mine for years. Before the current US recession, I had so many career change clients who just felt like their family had to come first. Again, they were not slouches but they just couldn’t be on the road 24/7, on call 24/7, or expected to skip every special event.

    Within the last year, I remember a father of four that was commuting from a project management role several states away, a 15 hour drive, whose youngest were twins under 1 year of age. The strain that puts on a family is ridiculous. He just wanted to find a position that would allow him to work in our state and be home for his wife and four children.

    Thank you for letting people know it is possible!
    .-= Julie Walraven | Resume Services´s last blog ..Are you suffering from lack of sleep =-.

    • Christine
      September 3, 2010 | 5:03 pm

      Thanks, Julie. That degree of sacrifice is difficult indeed. And while our communications systems – Skype, mobiles, texting etc, etc – are good, nothing beats the experience of simply being in the presence of the people that you love and who love you. I often hear people say that they need to be there for their families, but they need to be with their families for their own well-being too.

      In the case of this client, it took some time for him to get his feelers out there and working reliably for him to trust that he really could have a career and a life. I think an important first step is allowing yourself your own truth, and being willing to take the steps to bring it to life for you.

  6. Karen F.
    Twitter:
    September 3, 2010 | 6:06 pm

    Have to thank Julie for leading me to this post! For a lot of people it seems impractical to forego a good job to achieve work-life balance, but truly, who can be happy doing a job…knowing full well the family or both work and family will suffer?

    I think some other career rules that come to mind (and that I have trouble with)are: you have to be older than someone before they can be your boss; you have to put in more time in the company to get ahead (and often that means giving up vacation time); and if no one saw you do it, it can’t be wrong.

    Work can be crazy, but it shouldn’t overrun your life!

    Karen, The Resume Chick (on Google or Twitter for questions, comments or violent reactions)
    .-= Karen F.´s last blog ..If You’re Fresh Out of College- Here’s What Your Resume Should Focus On =-.

    • Christine
      September 6, 2010 | 10:57 am

      Thanks Karen and welcome! Julie’s a good friend of mine and I’m delighted to have connected with you through her.

      These career rules you list out here are very prevalent in some places, aren’t they? I like the “if no one saw you…” one. Makes me think of the one that goes “if everyone agrees, it must be right”!

  7. [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by theantiresume, The Resume Chick. The Resume Chick said: Great post! You should weigh in! RT @JulieWalraven READ: Warning: Not All Career Rules Are True http://ow.ly/2zd8u by @coblyn #careerchange [...]

  8. Jon Prial
    Twitter:
    September 6, 2010 | 3:17 am

    Clearly Bob’s old company (or at least the part he interacted with) didn’t get it and his new one does. It is going to take time but eventually more and more companies will understand that flexibility is a win-win for the company and the employee. I’ll never forget when I was leaving at the end of a day (vs. staying late) and my boss said, “Banker’s hours, eh?”. My response could have cost me my job (it was just a few words), but the next day I actually got an apology as I always got all my work done and more. Bottom line – work for the right company and stick to your principles.
    .-= Jon Prial´s last blog ..Eulogy- Work-Life and The Greatest Generation =-.

    • Christine
      September 6, 2010 | 10:58 am

      Great summary, Jon. “Work for the right company and stick to your principles”. Now, that’s a career rule that people should adopt!

  9. Ben
    September 6, 2010 | 9:45 pm

    It’s surprising how many of these unwritten rules there are in organisations out there. I think what disappoints me the most about Bob’s story is that the HRD (someone who really should of known better) supported the rules.

    There is another way though and your post Christine is a great description of that other way. The power is yours and yours alone.

    This reminds me of a Jim Rohn quote which goes something like this…”If you have no plan for you life someone else will and guess what? They don’t have much planned for you.”
    .-= Ben´s last blog ..What’s your flavour of choice =-.

    • Christine
      September 7, 2010 | 11:09 am

      The HRD’s example in this story was gutting. They really could have supported Bob as an example of a positive deviant in their company, but in truth they were too busy supporting their own political well-being.

      I love the Jim Rohn quote here. It’s so appropriate and thanks for sharing it, Ben!

  10. Melissa Cooley
    Twitter:
    September 7, 2010 | 1:13 am

    How wonderful that you were able to able to help Bob find a corporate culture that would be in line with how he wanted to live! So many employers (both for-profit and nonprofit) only pay lip service to the idea of a work/life balance. In the end, they will be the ones who have burnt-out employees and high turnover rates.

    • Christine
      September 7, 2010 | 11:15 am

      I couldn’t agree more, Melissa. I live in hope that employers will get the whole work/life thing one of these days. Sadly, at the moment, it’s just an espoused but not lived value for most.

Leave a Reply

Wanting to leave an <em>phasis on your comment?

CommentLuv badge
Trackback URL http://www.adifferentkindofwork.com/2010/09/02/warning-not-all-career-rules-true/trackback/