There I was, watching the last of the Six Nations rugby matches on Saturday. As a Scot, the highlight of the afternoon was Ireland vs Scotland in Dublin. History was already present for many reasons. Not only was it going to be Ireland’s last match at Croke Park, a venue steeped with traditions that had had to be overcome to allow the team to play there at all; but also, Ireland, having had a joined-up performance all season, were still in with a chance certainly of lifting the Triple Crown, and possibly winning the tournament.
Stack against this the Scot’s thorny relationship with success. Whilst many talented Scottish individuals down the years have done well, it’s not really in the country’s psyche to win. The unspoken cultural motto is “Try Hard (But never succeed)”. Bannockburn left a deep scar that the Scots cling to as part of its needed woundology. In rugby, and indeed in many other team sports, they constantly field teams of talented players and put on heroic performances, but there’s always something that prevents them from mobilising enough collective belief to be outright winners.
So, it was safe to say that on Saturday the odds were stacked against them. But they pulled off a blinder of a result. Here are four things that I believe contributed. Interestingly, these are things that could just as easily translate to those of you trying to change your own life-game.
Fitness
Frank Hadden, the previous team coach, was much slated. But one way he’d served the team well was to build on the work of Matt Williams, who had criticised the team’s fitness levels. Like Williams, Hadden saw that, if Scotland was to stand a chance of winning against world class sides like New Zealand and South Africa, they’d need to work at having the strength and resistance to endure eighty minutes of hard battle. Thanks to both Williams and Hadden, current coach Andy Robinson inherited a team that, before you consider any other aspect of play, was simply able to go onto the field and compete.
So, questions to ask yourself if you’re trying to fundamentally change something in your own life, are: In what ways do you need to be “fit”? How can you build your own physical or psychological strength and endurance?
Experiencing failure
The first match of this year’s Six Nations saw the Scots leading against the Welsh 18-9 at half time. But two things happened. First, two key Scottish players were seriously injured: Glasgow Warriors’ Thom Evans, who subsequently had to have spinal surgery; and Chris Paterson, who’d just won his 100th cap, who injured his kidney. Second, unaccustomed to such an outstanding lead, they began committing stupid errors and handed the game to their opponents, who won the match 31-24.
And I wonder, in what ways you feel uncomfortable going out on a limb sometimes? What makes you wobble? How do you give your game over to your opponents, even if only your internal ones?
Risk-taking
After the Cardiff match, the squad had a choice to play out its role as underdogs or learn from experience. It chose the latter. Robinson began to experiment with the players, bringing on Dan Parks on as Fly Half, and Johnnie Beattie on as a Forward. Whilst, the former is a figure of real controversy as a player and as an individual in Scotland, the latter has been criticised for being too much in the shadow of his renowned Scottish rugby playing father. They both had things to prove for themselves and for Scotland.
In addition to experimental player choice, you could see the team trying things out on the pitch, being faster off the mark and making smarter tackles. These things together began to bring a different feel to the Scottish team and although this didn’t initially translate into wins, the possibility started to become more evident.
Thinking about yourself, what risks do you need to take to challenge your own mould? What results will you begin to see that will let you know you’re being successful?
Breaking the mould
What Scot would have stood in Dan Parks boots one minute from the end of the match as he prepared to take a penalty kick that would clinch certain victory? It had been another of his magical kicks, landing the ball deep into the Irish half, that had set things up in the first place. Still, he had no map of recent Scottish success to model the possibility of a victory.
But Parks’ positive deviance defied the picture. He knew as soon as he’d kicked that the ball would go over. Andy Robinson, the team, and a few million Scots were rightfully jubilant.
What pictures and mental models do we hold that need to be smashed? What one thing do we need to do to breakthrough them?
Who knows what the Scots will do with this platform they have now built for themselves. My hope is that they’ll go on to show the world how awesome they are. I wish them courage and determination to do so.
No related posts.





What a great post! I also watched the rugby on Saturday, and had similar thoughts when they lost to Wales. Where were their heads then?
Did you watch the England France match afterwards? (Or were you too busy celebrating?) I found the increasingly negative commentary from Brian Moore, (beloved by all Scots-ha), really wore me down and began to jaundice my view of the match. He needed desperately to blame someone and he just couldn’t stop. Like sitting next to the most negative person in the office; emotions are contagious. How I miss dear old Bill. He personified the ‘right’ mindset!
Thank you, Jane. Much appreciated!
I DID watch the England France match afterwards and, yes, I thought Brian Moore was hysterical. His commentary became more of a (very biased!) commentary on the refereeing as opposed to the match. I was heard to say, “Shut the @?!* up!” to the television on more than one occasion as he really was spoiling the whole thing. He could just not say that England was having an off day! Yes, Bill McLaren is sorely missed – he was so positive, irrespective of the actual results.
My son met him a few times as he was always doing his research at the practise games. He gave him a famous Hawick ball! I don’t think there is a commentator alive who can touch him for sheer poetry and impartiality. RIP Bill.
Jane
PS Wonder why my photo isn’t showing up? probably a blessing in disguise…..
How wonderful for your son! That’s awesome.
And I can’t imagine why your photo isn’t showing, especially as it was doing so earlier across at Jim’s site. Odd…?
Twitter: adrianswinscoe
Hi Christine,
As a fellow Scot I sat and started watching the game on Saturday with little hope in my heart. But, as the game got going and reached 60 mins it become apparent that Scotland had decided to play a whole game this time. I think they used the opportunity to put to bed the pain of showing up for only 60 mins against both Wales and England. Like you, I hope they go on to great success. I think back fondly to the days of David Sole’s ’84 Grand Slam winning team. Ah, those were the days
Adrian
.-= Adrian Swinscoe´s last blog ..Teams and birds: lessons from nature =-.
So, you’re a fellow Scot, Adrian? That’s good to know.
Glad you enjoyed the game too. I hadn’t seen the “60 minutes” angle, but of course, you’re right. And what a difference that made. As the old saying goes, “The game’s not over, till it’s over.”
Having only really started watching the game in the 90s, I don’t have the David Sole memories to look back on. You must tell me about them one of these days!
Take care!
Social comments and analytics for this post…
This post was mentioned on Twitter by coblyn: Four Lessons on Game-Changing From The Scottish Rugby Team http://goo.gl/fb/LLkO...
Hi Christine,
As a Scot still living in Glasgow I get to see Dan Parks and co on a regular basis as they play for Glasgow Warriors. I consider myself to thus be lucky. At club and national level I perceive the focus has been on fitness, strength, stamina, defence etc. The reasons for this were obvious back in 2003 when at the world cup Scotland only played 30 minutes against a supremely fit French team – playing 60 minutes (as Adrian noted) is actually a big improvement! And as you note Matt Williams’s involvement was in retrospect significant: he took the team to Stirling University Sports Centre and basically told them they weren’t in physical shape to be winners. Matt, an Australian and winning coach with Leinster, was uber critical and as a result lost the team and heirarchy support very quickly. It was too much for them to face. But in retrospect he did the most important job – he burst the bubble of complacency! Rugby was, after all, no longer an amateur sport and Scotland having accepted this much later than most teams have thus been playing catch-up even since. Perhaps there is an angle here Christine where being a winner means accepting the hard truths as early as possible otherwise you marginalise yourself? And we all know what that means: taking knocks, facing self-doubt, being surrounded by despair and utter negativity. I think Saturday was a watershed moment for this team but what they do next is in their hands – or the boot of Dan Parks or Chris Paterson……..
P.S. Yes Bill McClaren is badly missed. The BBC have moved from professional impartial commentary to partisan, dumbed-down and ignorant sniping. And as Jane notes with regard to Brian Moore his comments are jaundiced and for an ex-rugby player he seems to also be ignorant of the laws of the game. Shameful stuff from the BBC who also don’t give fair national representation in the studio – that would at least counter the insular partisan nature of BBC Six Nations output. Dear God bring back Bill McClaren.
Great commentary here, Bobby, on the much needed progress of the Scottish team over the last years. I’m jealous of you being able to watch Glasgow Warriors regularly!
Your point about winners accepting hard truths early is well made. Facing self-doubt, and looking realities in the face takes great courage. It’s easier to stay with mediocrity than to step away from it.
As for Bill, as much as I wish it were not true, sadly there are some miracles that cannot be performed
Great job at drawing analogies from the game.. I have only one issue with your post (LOL) and that is your failure to mention AUSTRALIA as a world class rugby team…
.-= Mick Morris´s last blog ..How much value are you REALLY giving? =-.
Mick, you’re right, that’s a SHOCKING omission! LOL!!
Good to hear your voice and thanks for the comment.
Twitter: adrianswinscoe
Hi Christine,
Aye, a fellow Scot and just noticed an error in my comment. It was 1990 when David Sole (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Sole) led Scotland to the Grand Slam. Ooops!
Cracking team and great memories. I wait with baited breath for them to return.
Adrian
.-= Adrian Swinscoe´s last blog ..Teams and birds: lessons from nature =-.
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Jim Connolly, Katrina Kibben, Monster Careers, drbret, Christine Clark and others. Christine Clark said: RT @jimconnolly: RT @coblyn: Latest post: Four Lessons on Game-Changing From The Scottish Rugby Team: http://bit.ly/bEC74C [...]
Twitter: JulieWalraven
Great Analogies, Christine… since I am in the US, rugby is pretty unfamiliar to me since we watch football and of course, living in Wisconsin, I would be a Packer fan. But your post still caught my attention, “Thinking about yourself, what risks do you need to take to challenge your own mould? What results will you begin to see that will let you know you’re being successful?”
As you know, this has been a year of breaking the mold for me. As I write this, I am in Baltimore, just relaxing after three days of intense discussion and learning at the Career Thought Leaders Conference. As I met my colleagues, I was surprised to see how many knew so much about me and even knew my work. My website had apparently been visited frequently by my colleagues and my online presence was well-known.
As I continue to break out of the mould of my prior co-mingled role of career strategist combined with a whitewater operations management role to focus only on the career side, I am smashing the barriers that stood between a real connection to my industry and real personal growth.
.-= Julie Walraven | Resume Services´s last blog ..Moving from Online to Real Life =-.
Julie, without a doubt you are going out on a limb in terms of your own work and career right now, and the energy and enthusiasm you have for the whole process is infectious!
I think what you’ve done in terms of getting yourself on a plane to Baltimore and going to the Career Thought Leaders Conference has been symbolic of your stepping into your own career thought leader’s shoes. The reception that you’ve had is evidence of that!
It’s delightful watching you breaking your own mould and being part of your journey. Go girl!
Twitter: marcwinitz
What is with you Scots and not being able to win? OK, loved the post for the very valuable lessons you pointed out. But all I could think about reading this was being in Edinburgh two years ago watching Scotland play Italy in the European Cup Football quarter finals at Hampden Park and losing in the final minutes. Honestly Christine, it was great. Not that Scotland lost but that as an American I was able to see the whole national psyche on display in such an enormous way. So your post has a lot of value to me (one person) knowing what it means to this great nation to win. A wonderful post on many levels.
I don’t know what the Scots’ thing is about not being able to win. All I can tell you is that we’re pretty balanced on the issue, having chips on both shoulders
It’s great that you got to see this issue first hand (and indeed from Hampden Park, which is not a stone’s throw from where I used to live) – I’m sure you’ll have witnessed aspects of it, not only on the field, but from the seats of the stadium itself. We love the pathos of the valiant tryers who are never quite good enough. It gives us a sense of identity and belonging. So that, when we actually break through our own spell the victory is even more keen. It’s SO painful to be a Scot some time, but by the same token it’s such a beautiful country and its people so special that I can’t ever separate from my cultural heritage!
Thanks for dropping by, Marc!
Great post Christine. I cheered for you when Dan Parks struck that penalty.
The interesting lesson I took from the game was from Dan himself. When he struck that penalty there was no doubt in his mind that it would go in. But it didn’t just go in. It went as straight as an arrow from what seemed like an impossible angle.
The lesson I got was that it’s the hours and hours on the training ground, the hours building the fitness, the time spent mentally preparing yourself is what brings success. Everything Dan Parks had done in his rugby career came together at that moment to produce that result. That’s what success is about. Building the skills and the fitness up over time and the stepping up to the plate when it’s your time.
Also I think it’s really interesting that Mick would bring up the all conquering Australian Rugby team but failed to mention that they choked under the pressure and lost to Scotland time they visited the mighty Hampdon Park. I’m just saying Mick
.-= Ben´s last blog ..Friday’s Personal Development Homework =-.
Your point about building the skills and the fitness and stepping up to the plate when it’s your time is spot-on, Ben. I think this is exactly what was going on for Dan, and I’m delighted you shared this personal parallel for you.
And I’d forgotten about that last Australian game in Scotland. Kept that one quiet, Mick!
One defeat and you want to beat me up about it…… nobodies perfect you know (althoughtthe Wallabies come a lot closer than those other teams…LOL)
.-= Mick Morris´s last blog ..What if…… =-.
Brilliant, Mick! I’d love to be able to give some smart counter-jibe, but sadly for us Scots at least, what you’re saying is true. LOL!!
[...] and Dr. Bret has tweeted a link to a fine piece on Scotland’s final triumph last year – Four Lessons on Game-Changing From The Scottish Rugby Team – hinged on an embrace of [...]